The Court System in a Time of Crisis: COVID-19 and Issues in Court Administration

Authors

Richard Haigh, Osgoode Hall Law School of York University
Bruce Preston, School of Public Policy & Administration, York University

Document Type

Article

Abstract

Canadian courts, in many ways, are neither efficient nor effective. This has been clear for many years. This article looks broadly at how little attention has been paid to court administration in the past, especially during times of crisis, and examines the impact the current pandemic may have on the future of Canadian court administration. In this vein, we examine emergency plans in general before turning to pandemic-specific plans and how, especially in Canada, these have been found wanting during this current crisis. Like most organizations, courts have developed plans – business contingency (BCPs) in Canada and continuity of operation (COOPs) in the United States—laying out policies and processes to follow in an emergency. Yet none of the various disaster plans created by courts in both Canada and the United States highlight the role and importance technology would play. Despite the increasing use of remote access for hearings—there has been a great deal of success in scheduling appeal hearings remotely—most courts have been unable to operate at pre-pandemic levels. In fact, most courts have postponed the majority of their hearings and have had to push dockets forward. Postponing a large portion of the courts’ hearings will undoubtedly add to a backlog of cases and increase the administrative burden on operations once physical distancing is removed. But the change in attitude that has taken place over the past few months is arguably greater than the sum of all changes made over the last forty years since Carl Baar’s reference to courts being “horse-and-buggy” organizations. The pandemic has provided a perfect occasion—no doubt forced but relatively low-risk—to try new things. Our position is that steps need to be taken to ensure that an increased reliance on “privileged access to technology” during COVID-19 does not lead to an “exacerbation of denial of access to justice.”

Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 4.0 License.

Citation Information

Haigh, Richard and Preston, Bruce. "The Court System in a Time of Crisis: COVID-19 and Issues in Court Administration." Osgoode Hall Law Journal 57.3 (2021) : 869-904.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.60082/2817-5069.3608
https://digitalcommons.osgoode.yorku.ca/ohlj/vol57/iss3/11